Biblical church discipline is a process, rooted in Scripture, by which a local church addresses sin within its membership, with the goals of restoring the erring individual to fellowship with God and the church, protecting the purity of the church, and upholding the honor of Christ. It involves a series of steps, as outlined in Matthew 18:15-17 and other passages, progressing from private admonition to, if necessary, public rebuke and even excommunication, always carried out with a spirit of love and a desire for repentance and reconciliation.
📖 1. What Is Church Discipline?
Church discipline is a loving, corrective process initiated by the church to address willful, ongoing, and unrepentant sin in the life of a professing believer, with the ultimate goal of restoration, repentance, and reconciliation. It is an act of love—not judgmentalism—carried out with gentleness, humility, and gospel hope.
Church discipline is not revenge or punishment; it is discipleship in action.
Church discipline includes any correction that helps a believer grow in holiness, as it aims to nurture spiritual development and maintain the integrity of the faith community. However, formal church discipline often refers to the process outlined in Matthew 18:15–17, which provides a structured approach for addressing sin within the church. This process encourages believers to confront one another in love to restore relationships, emphasizing the importance of accountability and reconciliation. The guidance found in these verses highlights the responsibilities of both the individual and the church body, ensuring that discipline is administered in a way that seeks restoration rather than punishment. Ultimately, church discipline serves not only to correct but also to strengthen the community of believers, promoting a healthier spiritual environment for everyone involved.
🎯 2. The Purpose of Church Discipline
A. To Restore the Wayward Believer
“Brothers, if anyone is caught in any transgression, you who are spiritual should restore him in a spirit of gentleness.” – Galatians 6:1
The word restore in Greek (καταρτίζω, katartizō) means to set a broken bone or mend a net. It is healing, not harming; this term beautifully encapsulates the process of healing in both a physical and spiritual sense. When a bone is broken, it requires careful realignment and time to heal before it can function normally again. Similarly, the act of restoration in a spiritual context involves patience, love, and understanding. The goal is always the spiritual good of the person in sin, serving as a guiding light to gently lead them back to their rightful place in fellowship with God and His people. This process underscores the importance of community support and the belief that everyone is worthy of forgiveness and a second chance, reflecting the profound mercy and grace that characterizes divine love. Through restoration, individuals can find healing from their past mistakes, enabling them to rebuild relationships and walk in a renewed sense of purpose and connection.
B. To Protect the Church Body
“Don’t you know that a little leaven leavens the whole lump?” – 1 Corinthians 5:6
Unchecked sin spreads—morally, relationally, and spiritually. If the church ignores open rebellion or sin, it sends the message that holiness doesn’t matter, leading to a culture where ethical standards are diminished, and harmful behaviors are tolerated. This erosion of moral boundaries can create divisions within the congregation, ultimately jeopardizing the community’s unity and mission. Church discipline, when practiced with love and clarity, protects the purity, peace, and witness of the congregation. It serves as a vital mechanism for fostering accountability among members, encouraging spiritual growth, and reaffirming the commitment to living a life that reflects Christ’s teachings. In this way, discipline reinforces the significance of holiness, reminding the community that their collective integrity is essential for fulfilling their calling in the world.
C. To Honor Christ and His Holiness
“Be holy, for I am holy.” – 1 Peter 1:16
“As obedient children, do not be conformed to the passions of your former ignorance.” – 1 Peter 1:14
The church is called to reflect God’s holiness, an essential aspect of our faith that necessitates a commitment to spiritual integrity. When we exercise biblical discipline, we show that we take sin seriously because we take God seriously. This means understanding the weight of our actions and their impact on our relationship with the Divine and with one another. In doing so, we not only uphold the moral standards set forth in Scripture but also cultivate an environment of accountability and growth, where members are encouraged to pursue righteousness and uphold the teachings of Christ in their daily lives. Through this process, we demonstrate our reverence for God’s authority and invite others to join us in striving for a deeper, more authentic faith that honors His character.
📜 3. Key Principles of Biblical Church Discipline
1. Discipline Is an Act of Love
“Those whom I love, I reprove and discipline.” – Revelation 3:19
“For the Lord disciplines the one he loves…” – Hebrews 12:6
Just as parents discipline children because they love them, wishing to guide them towards a better path and help them grow into responsible individuals, God disciplines us—and calls the church to do the same in love, emphasizing the importance of nurturing one another through accountability and correction. This divine guidance encourages us to reflect on our actions, fostering a community where love and truth coexist, and where each member supports one another in their spiritual journey. By understanding that discipline is a form of love, we can embrace it as part of our growth, leading to stronger relationships both with God and within the church.
2. It Must Be Done in Humility and Gentleness
“Restore him in a spirit of gentleness… keeping watch on yourself, lest you too be tempted.” – Galatians 6:1
“Judge not, that you be not judged.” – Matthew 7:1 (misused verse that calls for humility, not silence)
Church discipline must never be motivated by pride, legalism, or anger. Instead, it must be approached with a heart full of love and compassion, ensuring that the well-being of the individual is prioritized above all. It should be bathed in prayer, grace, and self-awareness, as these elements help to cultivate a spirit of humility and understanding among all involved. Through diligent prayer, we seek divine guidance and wisdom, while grace reminds us of our own imperfections and the forgiveness we have received. Self-awareness fosters an environment where we can reflect on our own faults, allowing us to engage in discipline not as a form of punishment but as a path toward restoration and healing within the community. By emphasizing these principles, church discipline can lead to growth and reconciliation rather than division and resentment.
3. It Is Part of Discipleship
“Go and make disciples… teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you.” – Matthew 28:19–20
Discipline is not a separate activity from discipleship—it’s a necessary part of helping believers grow in obedience to Christ and develop a deeper, more profound relationship with Him. It involves a committed effort to guide individuals through the challenges they face in their spiritual journey, ensuring they not only understand the teachings of Christ but also apply them in their daily lives. By incorporating discipline into the process of discipleship, we provide a structured framework that encourages believers to embrace accountability, establish healthy spiritual habits, and cultivate a lifestyle that reflects Christ’s values, ultimately leading to transformation and maturity in their faith.
4. It Is a Process, Not a Reaction
Discipline should be measured, biblical, and orderly, not impulsive or emotionally driven. It is essential to establish a framework that guides one’s actions and decisions, ensuring that they are rooted in wisdom and aligned with moral principles. Such an approach fosters personal growth and stability, allowing individuals to navigate life’s challenges with purpose and clarity. Incorporating a structured methodology encourages consistency, enabling the development of habits that are not swayed by fleeting emotions or external pressures. Ultimately, a disciplined life is one that reflects inner strength and steadfastness, promoting resilience in the face of adversity.
🔄 4. The Steps of Church Discipline (Matthew 18:15–17)
Jesus gives a clear, step-by-step guide for addressing sin in the church. These steps are patient and redemptive.
Step 1: Private Confrontation
“If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone.” – Matthew 18:15
- Go one-on-one in love, cherishing moments together and building a deep emotional connection that transcends the ordinary.
- The ultimate goal is quiet, gentle restoration, allowing for a soothing and peaceful healing process that nurtures both the body and mind.
- Avoid gossip or public exposure, as it can lead to misunderstandings, damage relationships, and create an uncomfortable environment for all involved.
- If they repent sincerely and wholeheartedly, with a genuine desire to change their ways, the matter is resolved—praise God!
Practical tip: Teach members how to have these conversations with grace and clarity.
Step 2: Bring One or Two Witnesses
“But if he does not listen, take one or two others along with you…” – Matthew 18:16
- If private appeal fails, bring wise, spiritually mature witnesses who can provide insight, guidance, and support during the discussion, ensuring that the matter is handled with care and reverence.
- They confirm facts, provide accountability, and gently urge repentance, while also fostering understanding and promoting personal growth through constructive dialogue.
- Their consistent and unwavering presence also serves to protect against false accusations, providing support and foster a sense of security for those involved.
Note: These are not “sides” but spiritual allies in seeking peace.
Step 3: Tell It to the Church
“If he refuses to listen to them, tell it to the church.” – Matthew 18:17a
- Now the issue moves to church leadership, and potentially to the congregation, presenting a vital opportunity for thoughtful discussion and reflection on the values and principles that guide their community.
- The church calls the person publicly to repent, urging the individual to acknowledge their wrongdoing in front of the congregation and seek forgiveness for their actions in order to restore their relationship with both God and the community.
- Still, the tone is redemptive and prayerful, reflecting a deep sense of hope and a longing for spiritual connection amidst life’s challenges and struggles.
Depending on the context, this may happen through elders, a church meeting, or a statement to the congregation. In many communities, elders play a crucial role in guiding discussions and providing wisdom, often sharing experiences that resonate deeply with the members present. A church meeting serves as a structured forum for addressing important issues, fostering collaboration and understanding among the congregation, while an official statement delivered to the congregation can offer clarity on beliefs or actions the church intends to take, reinforcing a sense of unity and purpose within the community. This multifaceted approach ensures that everyone’s voice has a chance to be heard, creating a rich tapestry of mutual respect and shared values.
Step 4: Separation from Fellowship
“If he refuses to listen even to the church, let him be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector.” – Matthew 18:17b
- The person is no longer treated as a believer in good standing, reflecting a significant shift in their status within the community and indicating potential repercussions on their relationships and support systems.
- This may involve removal from membership, which can impact an individual’s standing within the organization, leadership roles, potentially affecting their ability to influence decisions and guide others, or communion, which signifies a deeper spiritual connection that may be compromised.
- The church is to continue praying for them with a heart of hope, trusting that their situation will improve and that they will find the strength to overcome the challenges they face in their lives.
Paul models this in 1 Corinthians 5, instructing the church to remove an unrepentant man “so that his spirit may be saved.” This instruction highlights the importance of maintaining the purity and integrity of the church community, emphasizing that unchecked sin can lead to broader consequences for the congregation. By taking this difficult step, the church not only seeks the spiritual restoration of the individual but also aims to protect the overall health of its members, fostering an environment where repentance and transformation are possible. In this way, Paul emphasizes the principle of accountability, urging believers to lovingly confront sin in order to ultimately draw each other closer to the grace of God.
🧩 When Should Church Discipline Be Applied?
Church discipline is generally reserved for:
- Persistent, unrepentant sin, not momentary failure (Galatians 6:1).
- Public, scandalous sin that affects the church’s witness (1 Corinthians 5).
- False teaching that misleads others (Titus 1:10–11).
- Divisiveness or slander (Titus 3:10).
Not every sin needs formal discipline—but all sin needs shepherding.
💡 What Is the End Goal?
1. Restoration of the Sinner
“You should rather turn to forgive and comfort him, or he may be overwhelmed by excessive sorrow.” – 2 Corinthians 2:6–8
After sincere repentance, the church should fully welcome the individual back with love, embracing their journey of redemption and healing. It is essential to create an environment that nurtures understanding and compassion, allowing the person to reintegrate into the community without judgment. The process should involve open arms and supportive conversations, ensuring that the individual feels valued and recognized for their efforts to change. By fostering a spirit of reconciliation and encouragement, the church can help restore faith and strengthen bonds within the congregation.
2. Health of the Church
The body is inherently protected from hypocrisy, harm, and moral confusion, creating a sanctuary that fosters authenticity, integrity, and clarity of purpose. This protection serves as a vital shield against external influences that seek to undermine one’s principles, ensuring that the body remains a true reflection of the spirit and mind. Through a combination of intuitive instincts and learned wisdom, it navigates the complexities of existence while maintaining a steadfast commitment to genuine values and beliefs. As such, it not only defends against physical threats but also cultivates a profound inner strength that empowers individuals to face life’s challenges with confidence and resilience.
3. Glory to God
When the church reflects God’s holiness and love through discipline, it honors Christ before the world, showcasing the transformative power of His grace in the lives of believers. By embracing a posture of accountability and correction, the church not only nurtures spiritual growth but also illuminates the path of righteousness for others. This act of discipline becomes a beacon of hope, inviting those who may feel lost or burdened by sin to experience the redemptive love of Christ. Such a commitment to embodying God’s truth encourages unity among church members and demonstrates the profound impact of living in accordance with His divine will, ultimately drawing others to the beauty of the gospel.
✅ Summary Table: The Church Discipline Process
| Step | Action | Scripture | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Private confrontation | Matthew 18:15 | Restoration with minimal exposure |
| 2 | Small group correction | Matthew 18:16 | Establish truth, support reconciliation |
| 3 | Church involvement | Matthew 18:17a | Corporate call to repentance |
| 4 | Formal separation | Matthew 18:17b; 1 Cor. 5:13 | Show seriousness of unrepentance, protect church |
🕊️ Final Encouragement: Discipline Reflects the Gospel
Church discipline isn’t about shame. It’s about truth in love, expressing our commitment to one another as a faith community grounded in grace. Jesus bore the penalty for sin so that we could be forgiven, transformed, and restored, allowing us to experience a relationship characterized by mercy and understanding. When we discipline biblically, we reflect His heart for repentance and renewal, recognizing that the goal is not condemnation but rather reconciliation and growth in faith. It is a vital practice that encourages accountability while nurturing a spirit of compassion, ultimately leading us all towards a deeper understanding of God’s will for our lives. By fostering an environment of support and care, we help each other to navigate the struggles of sin, ensuring that we remain united in our pursuit of holiness, joy, and a closer walk with Christ.
“For the Son of Man came to seek and to save the lost.” – Luke 19:10
budi hidajat 